Future Generali

Does India have a high income tax rate? An analysis

The income tax rate for India follows a progressive tax regime, which means that individuals who earn more pay a higher share of taxes as compared to others. Moreover, some citizens often complain about the personal income tax burden in India.

In the latest Union Budget for the years 2019-2020, the surcharge rate for persons with an income between ₹2 crores to ₹5 crores was raised to 25% from the existing 15%. For individuals with an income more than ₹5 crores, the surcharge is now 37%. Since surcharge is the additional levy imposed on individuals drawing high incomes, the effective tax rate on individuals earning more than ₹5 crores is now 42.74%.

Compared to countries such as Canada, the U.K., the U.S.A. and China, the income tax rate for India is lower. While India’s highest tax rate is 42.74%, Canada’s highest rate is 54.0%. While the U.K. and China both levy their highest taxes at 45%, the highest tax rate in the U.S.A. is 50.3%.

While the highest tax rate is one measure that is analysed to compare taxation systems, it is necessary to compare effective, average tax rates. Taking rupees as a metric here for better understanding:

  • Canada: Among the 5 countries studied here, Canada has the highest effective tax rate. While the population earning more than ₹6 crore are taxed at 51.4%, those earning about ₹1 crore are subjected to taxes at a rate of 38.88%; which is significantly higher than other countries’.
  • China: In China, the tax rate imposed on individuals earning between ₹1 crore to ₹2 crore is 26.81%, while those earning more than ₹6 crore are subjected to taxes at a rate of 41.97%.
  • The U.K.: For persons earning an income between ₹1 crore to ₹2 crore in the U.K., taxes are levied at a rate of 29.13%. Meanwhile, those earning upwards of ₹6 crore are expected to pay taxes at a rate of 42.1%.
  • The U.S.A.: While the U.S.A. has the second highest tax rate for the highest earners, at 44.7%, it is low for those earning between ₹1 crore to ₹2 crores. Those individuals are subjected to a tax rate of merely 28.2%, which is lower than India’s.

In conclusion, the income tax rate for India broadly appears to be on par with global peers. It is neither unreasonably high nor low.

Disclaimer and Links